The England flanker is one of the best in the world but he isn't currently pulling on the jersey due to an England Rugby ruling
Jack Willis is one of the best players on the planet right not but he is not being selected for England. A lot of fans may be questioning why but it comes down to a rule set by the Rugby Football Union.
The governing body requires players to play their club rugby in England in order to be eligible to play for the national side.
Related: All the upcoming England fixtures ahead of next year’s World Cup
Willis currently plays for Toulouse in France which is why he cannot be selected by Steve Borthwick.
Jack Willis: His club rugby journey
The flanker started his rugby journey at Reading Abbey before moving to Wasps in 2015. He came through the club’s academy and remained at the side until it went into administration in 2022.
The club’s demise led to the 29-year-old moving to Toulouse. Since he signed in 2022, he has won four Top 14 titles and one Champions Cup.
The RFU allowed Willis special dispensation, along with other Wasps players, to compete for England until the end of the 2023 Rugby World Cup because of the circumstances which led them to play club rugby in France. The last time Willis played for England was in their bronze final win against Argentina in 2023.
Related: Top 14 kits ranked
However, it was made clear after that point if they did not move back to the Premiership they could no long play for England.
Despite knowing he would have to play in England to compete for the national team, Willis remained in France.
He then signed a new long-term deal in 2024. The contract runs until 2029 but it has been reported that there is a break clause for the 2027/28 season. If he did return to England in that season he would be available for the 2027 RWC.
Related: Premiership fixtures
Do fans and media want Willis to play internationally?
Many fans and pundits want the eligibility rule to be changed for stars like Willis. England men’s most-capped player Ben Youngs has wrote for Planet Rugby about the flanker: “Jack’s ability around the breakdown seems to be far beyond what other players are capable of; he is just that effective. It’s just incredible how he bends, the positions he gets into. He is just amazing. World-class.”
Those sentiments have been echoed by many and it is easy to see why England fans want the rule changed. Willis was voted Top 14’s player of the year last season and was nominated for Champions Cup Player of the Year in 2025.
He is also solidly consistent in his performances and is a big game player. Willis scored two tries in the Top 14 final against Montpellier in the 2025/26 season.
The player himself is constantly asked about international rugby. When asked on the Love of Rugby podcast, he said he did not regret his decision.
“I don’t regret my decision to stay here at Toulouse,” he said. “The way it came about, I didn’t choose to leave England, but I chose to stay. I love it here, that is the first thing.
“As an athlete and a competitor, I don’t think I showed the best version of Jack Willis in an England shirt.”
Read more: Nations Championship questions answered
So for now, Willis will remain out of international rugby. He is also eligible for Ireland and could make the switch towards the end of 2026 after three years has lapsed on his last England cap, but it is rare for Ireland to cap a player who is not playing for one of their provinces.
Download the digital edition of Rugby World straight to your tablet or subscribe to the print edition to get the magazine delivered to your door.
Facts Only
* Jack Willis plays for Toulouse in France.
* Eligibility requires playing club rugby in England.
* Willis was not selected for England due to an England Rugby ruling.
* Willis played for Toulouse since moving in 2022.
* The RFU allowed special dispensation for Willis and other Wasps players to compete for England until the end of the 2023 Rugby World Cup.
* Willis played for England in their bronze final win against Argentina in 2023.
* Players must move back to the Premiership to remain eligible to play for England after the initial dispensation period.
* Willis signed a new long-term deal in 2024, running until 2029 with a reported break clause for the 2027/28 season.
Executive Summary
Full Take
The situation highlights a tension between individual sporting merit and administrative rule structures. The narrative pivots on an eligibility constraint imposed by the governing body, which separates the physical ability demonstrated by players from their contractual or logistical location. The public desire for greater inclusion stems from valuing Willis's performance—evidenced by his accolades in the Top 14, consistent performances, and recognition of his skill at the breakdown—which creates a conflict with the imposed geographical rule.
The player's own stated position reflects a choice prioritizing personal context over national representation: he did not regret staying at Toulouse, emphasizing that his decision was not an act of opting out of England but rather choosing to remain in a specific environment. This suggests that for some high-level athletes, the constraints of administrative rules operate as structural barriers rather than moral failings. Furthermore, the potential pathway to Ireland suggests that geographical affiliation may become a secondary consideration over national allegiance when system constraints are present, raising questions about the principle behind these eligibility rules. The pattern reveals a dynamic where subjective performance is weighed against objective regulatory frameworks, often leading to friction when the two systems do not align.
What does it imply about the relationship between professional sport and governance? How can sporting bodies balance the need for national team integrity with the recognition of elite talent whose careers are shaped by international movement? Does this reliance on geographical presence create an artificial limitation on the pool of global talent available to representative sides?
Sentinel — Human
The text reads like feature journalism providing context for an ongoing sports narrative, characterized by specific detail and a nuanced handling of player perspective.