Albert Einstein’s theory of special relativity can reshape chemical bonds within molecules, and researchers have just seen it happen for the first time.
The theory of special relativity describes how moving at speeds close to the speed of light would affect travellers’ experience of space and time. Because of this, it is usually associated with particle accelerators and spacefaring objects, but within some heavy atoms, electrons experience relativistic speeds too.
Advertisement
Lai-Sheng Wang at Brown University in Rhode Island and his colleagues have now managed to take an unprecedented look at how this breaks the standard notion of chemical bonds within a charged molecule made from bismuth and carbon.
Within the molecule, a bismuth atom and a carbon atom were connected by three bonds, one of which the researchers expected to be of “sigma” type and two of “pi” type. The difference between these two types stems from electrons’ quantum character – each electron is “smeared” across some region of space, instead of being a tight ball, and whether these regions overlap head on or side by side determines the type of chemical bond they create between the atoms.
In their experiment, Wang and his colleagues mapped the distribution of electrons throughout the molecule, effectively getting a look at its bonds. But instead of seeing electrons distributed in shapes associated with sigma and pi bonds, the team noticed that two of the bonds resembled two different mixes of sigma and pi shapes. “Their characters are different from our normal understanding,” says Wang. “You can’t really call it the sigma and pi.”
Subscriber-only newsletter
Sign up to Lost in Space-Time
Untangle mind-bending physics, maths and the weirdness of reality with our monthly, special-guest-written newsletter.
His team turned to Kirk Peterson at Washington State University, whose calculations ultimately showed that this mixing was a consequence of electrons near the bismuth nucleus feeling such a strong electromagnetic interaction that they moved at relativistic speeds. He says this effect hadn’t previously been captured in an experiment.
“The hardest thing about [studying] heavy elements is a lack of really good experimental data,” says Peterson. “To have such a beautiful experiment to be able to essentially compare very high-level theory to data is really a luxury.”
Wang says one important part of the new experiment is that he and his colleagues could make the molecule very cold before looking at its electrons. This dampened any jitters and excitations that would have made the final images imprecise.
“The methods they have used, both experimental and theoretical, are the best possible ones,” says Pekka Pyykkö at the University of Helsinki in Finland.
He says this relativistic reshaping of bismuth’s bonding with carbon could influence how organic bismuth compounds are used in chemical reactions. In fact, a recent study by researchers at the Max Planck Institute for Coal Research in Germany has already shown that relativistic effects help make this heavy metal a good catalyst of chemical processes.
Wang says the researchers now want to repeat their experiment but swap bismuth for elements close to it in the periodic table, so they can see when exactly special relativity makes the traditional chemical bond structure collapse.
Journal reference:
Science DOI: 10.1126/science.aei1285
Despite our ever-deepening understanding of the physical universe, we have yet to reach a consensus on the nature of time. In this talk, Jim Al-Khalili will forever change the way you think about the passage of time and your place within it.On Time: The physics that makes the universe tick
Topics:
Facts Only
* Lai-Sheng Wang and colleagues studied chemical bonds in a charged molecule of bismuth and carbon.
* The molecule has three bonds connecting a bismuth atom and a carbon atom, expected as one sigma bond and two pi bonds.
* Chemical bond type is determined by the quantum character of electrons' spatial distribution.
* The researchers mapped electron distribution to examine the bonds.
* Two bonds in the molecule resembled different mixtures of sigma and pi shapes.
* Kirk Peterson’s calculations suggested this mixing results from relativistic speeds experienced by electrons near the bismuth nucleus due to strong electromagnetic interaction.
* The experiment involved cooling the molecule to reduce measurement imprecision.
* A related study showed that relativistic effects can make heavy metals act as good chemical catalysts.
Executive Summary
Full Take
The investigation moves beyond standard quantum chemistry by directly probing how fundamental physics—special relativity—imprints itself onto molecular structure, challenging conventional definitions of chemical bonding. The core tension lies between the established framework of quantum mechanics describing electron "smearing" and the relativistic reality dictating electron motion in heavy elements. The finding that experimental observation reveals bond structures that deviate from expected sigma/pi classifications suggests a fundamental limitation or refinement in applying non-relativistic models to systems involving high velocities near massive nuclei.
The necessity of extreme experimental control, such as cooling the system, highlights the difficulty in isolating subtle relativistic effects in complex material systems. The subsequent plan to swap bismuth for lighter elements to pinpoint the exact collapse threshold introduces a vital test: determining whether the observed mixing is an emergent feature of relativity or a result of experimental artifact. This shifts the focus from merely observing a relativistic effect to quantifying its structural consequences within bonding theory, forcing a confrontation between theoretical predictions and empirical measurement in heavy element chemistry.
Bridge Questions: If these relativistic effects cause bond structure collapse, how does this mechanism scale across different atomic masses? What are the precise mathematical conditions under which the standard sigma/pi nomenclature becomes physically obsolete when incorporating relativistic mechanics into molecular orbital calculations? What is the comparative impact of this effect versus other relativistic corrections on the stability and reactivity of organic bismuth compounds in real-world catalytic processes?
Sentinel — Human
The text presents complex, specialized scientific information in an accessible narrative style, displaying the characteristics of human journalistic synthesis of peer-reviewed research.