Support justice-driven, accurate and transparent news — make a quick donation to Truthout today!
Israeli officials are reportedly urging the U.S. to join them in their public urging of Iranians to stage an uprising against their government, even as the Israeli government internally assesses that protesters would be “slaughtered” if they did so, demonstrating Israel’s blasé attitude toward Iranian lives amid its bombardments of the country.
According to reporting by The Washington Post published Tuesday, top Israeli officials relayed the message to U.S. diplomats in a cable that circulated in the U.S. embassy in Jerusalem on Friday. The cable said that Israeli officials assess that the Iranian government is “not cracking” and will “fight to the end” — despite hopes by U.S. and Israeli officials that they could “decapitate” the government and achieve collapse.
The cable further said that if Iranians were to stage more protests against their government, as they did in demonstrations earlier this year, “the people will get slaughtered,” Israeli officials said. According to UN Special Rapporteur on Iran Mai Sato, around 5,000 people were killed in the government crackdown on protests as of January, though it has been difficult to assess the precise number of deaths due to biases on all sides.
The cable, which summarized recent meetings by top Israeli officials and U.S. officials, said that nonetheless, Israeli officials are hoping for a revolt and that the U.S. should support such an uprising as well.
Critics have said that the cable demonstrates Israeli officials’ indifference toward whether civilians live or die, after years of Israel wantonly slaughtering civilians in Palestine and countries across the Middle East.
“This should not surprise anyone,” said Trita Parsi, executive vice president for the Quincy Institute, in a post on social media. “That the Israelis would use the Iranian people as cannon fodder in their war with the Islamic Republic was crystal clear to anyone who had followed the Israeli-Iranian rivalry in a clear-eyed way. Nor can anyone reasonably expect that Israel would act in the best interest of the Iranian people. Israel pursues its own interests, full stop.”
On the first day of the U.S. and Israel’s bombardments on February 28, U.S. President Donald Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu both put out video addresses urging the Iranian people to take up arms against their government as they rained death and destruction from the sky. Since then, the U.S. and Israel’s bombardments have killed over 1,400 people in Iran and injured at least 18,500, according to Iranian health officials. Israeli intelligence and military officials have long urged Iranians to protest against their government, and the U.S. has meddled in Iranian politics for decades.
“I think a lot of people will feel very betrayed by this assessment,” Iran analyst and Johns Hopkins University assistant professor Narges Bajoli told The Washington Post, saying that it would be viewed as exploiting Iranian lives for political gain.
An urgent appeal for your support: 8 Days to raise $45,000
Truthout relies on individual donations to publish independent journalism, free from political and corporate influence. In fact, we’re almost entirely funded by readers like you.
Unfortunately, donations are down. At a moment when independent journalism is urgently needed, we are struggling to meet our operational costs due to increasing political censorship.
Truthout may end this month in the red without additional help, so we’ve launched a fundraiser. We have 8 days to hit our $45,000 goal. Please make a tax-deductible one-time or monthly donation if you can.
Facts Only
* Israeli officials reportedly urged the U.S. to encourage Iranian protests.
* U.S. officials assessed that Iranian government was “not cracking” and would “fight to the end.”
* Israeli officials believed Iranian protests would result in “the people will get slaughtered.”
* UN Special Rapporteur on Iran, Mai Sato, reported around 5,000 deaths in the government crackdown.
* The cable was circulated on Friday.
* U.S. and Israeli bombardments have killed over 1,400 people in Iran.
* At least 18,500 people have been injured in Iran.
* U.S. President Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu urged Iranian protests.
* Israeli intelligence and military officials have long urged Iranians to protest.
* The U.S. has meddled in Iranian politics for decades.
* The cable summarized recent meetings by top Israeli and U.S. officials.
Executive Summary
Full Take
This exchange reveals a brutal calculation of human life, prioritizing strategic advantage over basic moral considerations. The “slaughtered” assessment from Israeli officials isn’t a spontaneous judgment, but a deliberate assessment of the potential cost of supporting a rebellion. The Steelman maneuver presents this as a straightforward exchange of information, but the underlying pattern is a classic Motte-and-Bailey, designed to obscure the true intent: to engineer a catastrophe for the Iranian people while framing it as a supportive gesture. The citation of UN Special Rapporteur Sato’s figures introduces a degree of uncertainty, reflecting the difficulty of verifying information in conflict zones and the biases inherent in reporting. However, the sheer number of reported deaths – 5,000 – underscores the severity of the situation and the deliberate escalation of violence.
The historical pattern mirrored here is the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, a sustained pattern of disproportionate force and disregard for civilian casualties. This isn’t simply a disagreement about strategy; it’s an echo of decades of state-sponsored violence against vulnerable populations. The “I think a lot of people will feel very betrayed” statement from Narges Bajoli exemplifies the use of a False Equivalence - framing the situation as a betrayal when the Israelis have a history of directly causing such betrayals. The urgency surrounding the fundraiser – "8 Days to raise $45,000" – feels almost cynical, a desperate attempt to exploit public sentiment. The underlying assumption is that people will readily accept a narrative of supporting a doomed uprising, obscuring the profound ethical questions at play. The potential for systemic drift, driven by the Israeli-Iranian rivalry, is undeniable. If this pattern continues, it’s a harbinger of further instability and escalating violence.
Patterns detected: ARC-0043 Motte-and-Bailey, ARC-0024 Ambiguity, ARC-0017 False Equivalence.
Sentinel — Likely Human
This article presents a factual account of reported Israeli urging for Iranian uprising, incorporating diverse perspectives. While the writing style is largely human, the reliance on attribution and the abrupt fundraising insertion suggest a potential for coordinated synthetic production, leaning towards likely human origin.