Supreme Court asylum decision burdens already overworked DOJ
Immigration Matters is a recurring series by César Cuauhtémoc García Hernández that analyzes the court’s immigration docket, highlighting emerging legal questions about new policy and enforcement practices.
Requests for asylum typically include complex descriptions of violence and fear followed by flight to the United States. In immigrat...
The article presents a deeply concerning snapshot of a legal system facing systemic collapse under the weight of its own mandate. Framing the Supreme Court’s decision as “technical” obscures a fundamental issue: the DOJ, operating through the EOIR, is demonstrably ill-equipped to handle the humanitarian crisis represented by asylum claims. The 1996 amendments, intended to constrain judicial review, have ironically created a bottleneck, amplifying the impact of shifting policy directives from adm...
