This analysis of Tolkien’s life through the lens of his Catholic faith presents a compelling narrative that blends scholarship with personal devotion. The strongest version of this narrative is its ability to bridge academic rigor and accessible apologetics, making Tolkien’s spirituality relevant to a broad audience. Ordway’s approach avoids overt proselytizing, instead inviting readers to engage with Tolkien’s faith as a key to understanding his work. The inclusion of supplementary materials—pr...