Image: hrw.org · rights & removal
US: Victims of Nicaraguan Government Risk Deportation
Reporting by Human Rights WatchRead the original at hrw.org
Executive Summary
US immigration authorities have detained at least eight Nicaraguan exiles whom the Ortega-Murillo government stripped of their nationality, including some with pending asylum claims. Seven of those detained were among 222 political prisoners expelled to the United States and declared "traitors" on February 9, 2023, to whom the U.S. granted humanitarian parole for two years. A journalist named Luis Galeano was stripped of his nationality on February 15, 2023, along with 93 other government critics. At least four of these individuals reportedly had pending asylum claims. Human Rights Watch stated that the United States is detaining and threatening to deport these critics, asserting that international law prohibits returning anyone to face persecution or torture.
At least two of the eight men were arrested during court appointments or asylum interviews between April and September 2026. While some individuals have been released, including Luis Galeano on bond, detention conditions at facilities like Krome have been documented as abusive, involving overcrowding and lack of basic necessities. The situation highlights concerns regarding the risk of persecution or torture if these individuals are returned to Nicaragua, especially considering the government's actions against critics and exiled groups.
Facts Only
* Eight Nicaraguan exiles were detained by US immigration authorities.
* The Ortega-Murillo government stripped nationality from these exiles.
* Seven detainees were among 222 political prisoners expelled to the U.S. on February 9, 2023.
* The U.S. granted humanitarian parole for two years to some of these individuals.
* Luis Galeano was stripped of nationality on February 15, 2023.
* At least four detainees reportedly had pending asylum claims.
* At least two of the eight were arrested during court appointments or asylum interviews between April and September 2026.
* Five of the eight men are reported to still be in detention.
* Luis Galeano was released on bond on September 26.
* Marvin Castellón Ubilla was released in July after more than two months in ICE custody.
* Two detainees had prior drug convictions in Nicaragua.
* Human Rights Watch documented abusive conditions at Krome detention center.
* The Nicaraguan government stripped nationality from 452 Nicaraguans between February 2023 and September 2024.
Full Take
The narrative weaves together the legal status of political exile, state-sponsored repression, and the complex mechanisms of international asylum and deportation law. The pattern observed is the deployment of detention and migration policies against those who dissent within an authoritarian regime, juxtaposed against stated international prohibitions against returning individuals to danger. The core tension lies between the sovereign actions of the Nicaraguan government in stripping nationality—an act that places exiles outside recognized legal protection—and the obligations of the receiving state, the United States, under international law regarding persecution and torture.
The implication is a systemic vulnerability: when states leverage citizenship status for political control, they create a predictable pathway for detention and deportation that can undermine refugee protections. The systematic effort by the Nicaraguan government to monitor and target exiled critics—as suggested by reports of transnational surveillance—suggests that the physical movement of these individuals between borders is not merely administrative but a calculated tactic of control.
The focus on ICE custody conditions and potential onward deportations demonstrates how abstract legal concepts (like asylum) are operationalized through physical control mechanisms (like detention centers). The calls for greater governmental transparency regarding detention statistics suggest that the mechanism itself becomes a site where accountability must be established to prevent procedural actions from becoming instruments of persecution.
What factors determine whether stated international prohibitions against return are effectively enforced, or if they serve merely as rhetorical counterpoints? How does the structural power imbalance between states mediate the application of these protective protocols when dealing with populations actively targeted by hostile governments? What mechanisms are necessary to ensure that humanitarian obligations supersede state security interests in transnational migration scenarios?
From the original · Human Rights Watch
(Washington, DC) – US immigration authorities have detained at least eight Nicaraguan exiles whom the Ortega-Murillo government has stripped of their nationality, including some with pending asylum claims, Human Rights Watch said today.Read the full story at hrw.org
