Skip to content
Chimera readability score 0.5221 out of 100, reading level.

Borrowers may be asked to replace damaged library books, as stains, moisture and other damage can make them unsuitable for circulation and risk harming other materials.
At Tallinn Central Library, stains and spills are a year-round issue — from coffee and leaking water bottles to seasonal fruits and berries. Even if a book appears intact, it may still need replacing if exposed to moisture.
"Books damaged by liquids or moisture generally aren't returned to shelves because they can cause damage to the surrounding books," said Triinu Seppam-Saar, the library's director of services.
She noted that moisture can lead to mold, damaging both books and furniture.
Because libraries often cannot determine what caused damage to a book, however, they take a strict approach.
"We usually only know if the patron tells us," Seppam-Saar said. "That's why we always ask for books with moisture or liquid damage to be replaced."
Seen and heard it all
Some borrowers will try to explain or excuse other wear or damage to their books, citing everything from conditions at home to younger siblings, melted ice cream and even pets, but libraries maintain the same standard regardless.
Librarians also encounter a variety of unusual items left between pages. Staff have found everything from toothpicks to nail clippers, and toilet paper used as bookmarks is a recurring theme.
"Once we found a pantyliner," said Liis Konovalov, a librarian at Südalinna Library. Unsure what to make of it at first, she finally settled on it just being what the reader had handy at the time.
Other unexpected finds have included artificial nails, eyelashes and even dead insects and spiders — likely accidental additions.
--
Editor: Aleksander Krjukov, Aili Vahtla

Facts Only

Actor: Borrowers, Tallinn Central Library
Action: Damaging books, replacing damaged books
Event: Stains, moisture, other damage make books unsuitable for circulation
Location: Tallinn Central Library
Timeline: Ongoing issue, year-round

Executive Summary

Libraries, particularly the Tallinn Central Library, face issues with borrowers damaging books, leading to requests for replacement of such damaged materials. Liquids, moisture, and other factors can render books unfit for circulation and potentially damage surrounding resources. The library maintains a strict approach towards handling damaged books due to uncertainty regarding causes. Borrowers often attempt to explain or excuse the wear and tear on their books, citing various factors like household conditions and accidents involving pets. Librarians have encountered a variety of unusual items left between pages, including toilet paper used as bookmarks and even dead insects.

Full Take

As libraries function as repositories of knowledge and cultural heritage, the request for damaged books to be replaced may have significant implications. This situation raises questions about the responsibility of borrowers towards the preservation of these resources. It also highlights the need for clear guidelines and education on how to properly handle library materials. The incidental finds between pages could potentially reflect broader patterns of carelessness or disregard for library property. The library's strict approach towards damaged books may be a form of risk management, but it could also lead to misunderstandings with borrowers who are not aware of the potential consequences of minor damages.
Patterns detected: ARC-0043 Motte-and-Bailey (the library takes a strict approach without providing specific guidelines for borrowers), ARC-0024 Ambiguity (unclear reasons for damage and responsibility)