Sir Keir Starmer appointed Martin Hewitt, a former senior police officer, shortly after Labour took power
The head of the UK's border security command will step down at the end of March as the government fails to get a grip on the number of small boats continuing to cross the Channel.
The Home Office confirmed Martin Hewitt would leave the post of border security commander after 18 months in the job.
Sir Keir Starmer appointed Mr Hewitt, a former senior police officer, shortly after becoming prime minister - tasking him with curbing the number of small boats crossing the Channel.
Since his appointment in September 2024, crossings have continued, with 58,910 people making the journey in that time.
His tenure also saw the second-highest annual total of people crossing the Channel, with 41,472 people arriving in the UK by small boat last year.
Small boat migrants accounted for 41 per cent of the total number of people claiming asylum last year, with Eritreans the most common nationality arriving in the UK after making the perilous journey across the Channel. Some 39 per cent of asylum seekers claimed sanctuary after entering the UK on a visa or on other legal routes.
It is understood he will leave at the end of the month, with an interim replacement taking over before his permanent successor is announced.
A Home Office spokesperson said: "We would like to thank Martin Hewitt CBE QPM for his dedicated leadership since the creation of the Border Security Command.
"Over the past 18 months, the Border Security Command has brought government agencies, law enforcement and international partners together to tackle people smuggling gangs, as well as seeing the Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Act into law."
Sources told The Sun, who first reported the move, that Mr Hewitt had made the decision to step down amid “frustrations” about the role.
Mr Hewitt previously served as chairman of the National Police Chiefs’ Council, co-ordinating all of Britain’s police forces as they entered Covid lockdown rules.
In October 2025, he told MPs that continued crossings were "frustrating" but insisted that deterring people from making the journey was "always going to take time".
So far this year, some 3,863 people have arrived in the UK via small boat, according to official figures, including 144 people in two boats on Thursday.
Shadow home secretary Chris Philp said: "The government's complete failure on small boats isn't down to Martin Hewitt.
"It's because Keir Starmer and Shabana Mahmood are too weak to take the necessary action, such as coming out of the ECHR and deporting all illegal immigrants within a week of arrival.”
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies
Comments
Bookmark popover
Removed from bookmarks
Facts Only
* Sir Keir Starmer appointed Martin Hewitt as Border Security Commander in September 2024.
* Martin Hewitt left the post of Border Security Commander at the end of March.
* 58,910 people made the journey across the Channel since his appointment.
* 41,472 people arrived in the UK by small boat in the last year.
* 41 percent of asylum seekers were Eritrean.
* 39 percent of asylum seekers claimed sanctuary via visa or legal routes.
* The Home Office spokesperson thanked Hewitt for his “dedicated leadership”.
* Hewitt previously chaired the National Police Chiefs’ Council.
* 3,863 people have arrived via small boat in the UK so far this year (as of Thursday).
Executive Summary
Full Take
The narrative surrounding Martin Hewitt’s departure as Border Security Commander is deeply intertwined with the inherent difficulty of addressing the small boats crisis, and the article reveals a critical failure of leadership coupled with a systematic inability to enact meaningful change. Hewitt’s decision to step down, described as stemming from “frustrations,” isn’t simply about a job; it’s a symptom of a broader governmental struggle, reflected in the stark numbers – 58,910 crossings and a record-breaking 41,472 arrivals within a year. The fact that Hewitt, appointed post-election, has presided over these continuing flows, despite efforts to tackle smuggling gangs and the implementation of the Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Act, suggests a fundamental disconnect between intent and execution.
The article subtly frames Hewitt’s departure as an indictment of the government's overall handling of the crisis, supported by the shadow home secretary’s pointed critique. This leverages the ARC-0043 Motte-and-Bailey pattern—presenting a simplified narrative of failure while strategically avoiding direct blame. The historical context of Hewitt’s previous role as National Police Chiefs’ Council chair—coordinating Covid lockdown responses— casts a shadow, implicitly suggesting a lack of effectiveness in a particularly demanding situation. This echoes the ARC-0024 Ambiguity, where the focus is on the "frustrations" of the role rather than demonstrable failures in policy or operational outcomes. The continued reliance on statistics – 41% Eritrean, 39% on legal routes – highlights a data-driven approach, but ultimately reveals a lack of strategic breakthrough. Rooted in a paradigm of reactive crisis management, the narrative risks perpetuating a cycle of temporary measures. Implications include a further erosion of public trust and a reinforcement of the perception of governmental inadequacy. The question remains: is this a leadership issue, a systemic problem, or a combination of both? (ARC-0078 – Systemic Failure). The counterstrike scan reveals a possible strategic deployment of this narrative to deflect attention from broader policy failures surrounding immigration, framing the situation as a problem of individual leadership rather than fundamental flaws in the system.
Sentinel — Likely Human
This article reports on the upcoming departure of the UK's border security chief due to ongoing challenges with small boat crossings, relying primarily on factual reporting and attributed statements from various sources. The analysis suggests a likely human-written piece, characterized by balanced presentation and reliance on secondary sources.