House Committee on Justice Vice Chairperson and San Juan City Representative Ysabel Zamora on Saturday expressed confidence that the lower chamber has enough numbers to impeach Vice President Sara Duterte.
At a news forum in Quezon City, Zamora was asked if she was confident that the House of Representatives has sufficient votes to transmit impeachment complaints against Duterte to the Senate so that the Vice President's trial would commence.
"We believe that we have the numbers. We need one-third or around 106 [votes] if I'm not mistaken. We have the numbers," she said.
However, the lawmaker said there are qualms among congressmen about proceeding with the Vice President's impeachment.
"I will admit to you that the numbers are not as much as the numbers last year," Zamora said.
In February last year, the lower chamber impeached Duterte with 215 votes, exceeding the required one-third threshold or 102 votes, thus sending the Articles of Impeachment against the Vice President to the Senate.
The upper chamber, however, did not convene into an impeachment court while the Supreme Court upheld its ruling that the Articles of Impeachment against Duterte were unconstitutional.
Last week, the House justice panel found that the two impeachment complaints against the Vice President were sufficient in grounds, with the hearing to find probable cause able to proceed.
The two impeachment complaints against the Vice President allege betrayal of public trust and culpable violation of the Constitution, among other offenses, stemming from the alleged misuse of P612.5 million in confidential funds and threats to kill President Ferdinand "Bongbong" Marcos Jr. and his family.
"Congressmen have read the complaints and they believe that we are correct in declaring that it is sufficient in form, sufficient in substance and that the affidavits are sufficient to show that there is probable cause," Zamora said.
"Of course, we still have to go through the Committee on Justice hearing to declare probable cause," she said.
GMA News Online has requested comment from Duterte's camp regarding Zamora's statements, but it has yet to respond as of posting time.
Meanwhile, several lawyers filed a petition before the Supreme Court asking for a temporary restraining order (TRO) preventing the House of Representatives from proceeding with the impeachment complaints against Duterte.
Echoing House Justice Committee chair and Batangas Representative Gerville Luistro's position that the panel will proceed despite the TRO petition, Zamora said the committee is following what the Supreme Court stated in its ruling regarding Duterte's impeachment.
"The House Committee on Justice is tasked to finish this within 60 session days," she said.
"We will continue with our proceedings… the House is on recess but the justice committee will continue," she added.
Luistro earlier said the petition cannot get in the way of the House's constitutional and sole mandate to initiate impeachment proceedings.
"We have not yet received nor reviewed the actual petition, but as with any legal pleading, we will study it carefully once it is formally served, and we will respond. [But] the filing of a petition, by itself, does not suspend the constitutional functions of a co-equal branch," Luistro said in a statement. — VDV, GMA Integrated News
Facts Only
Actors: House Committee on Justice, Batangas Representative Gerville Luistro, San Juan City Representative Ysabel Zamora, Vice President Sara Duterte, several lawyers
Events: the committee found that the two impeachment complaints against Duterte are sufficient in grounds and will proceed to find probable cause; several lawyers filed a petition before the Supreme Court asking for a TRO preventing the House of Representatives from proceeding with the impeachment complaints against Duterte
Timeline: ongoing, with no specific dates mentioned
Locations: Quezon City (news forum), not specified for the Supreme Court petition
Executive Summary
Full Take
Steelman: The House Committee on Justice is moving forward with the impeachment complaints against Vice President Sara Duterte, as they believe there are sufficient grounds to proceed. The two complaints allege betrayal of public trust and culpable violation of the Constitution, among other offenses. The committee is following its constitutional mandate to initiate impeachment proceedings despite the Supreme Court's ruling that the Articles of Impeachment against Duterte were unconstitutional last year.
Patterns detected: ARC-0043 Motte-and-Bailey, ARC-0024 Ambiguity (the article mentions both the successful impeachment vote last year and the current insufficient numbers, suggesting a potential retreat to a weaker position if necessary).
Root Cause: The impeachment proceedings against Vice President Sara Duterte are part of the ongoing political tension within the Philippines, with some members of Congress seeking to hold her accountable for alleged corruption and constitutional violations.
Implications: The outcome of these impeachment proceedings could have significant implications for the administration of President Ferdinand "Bongbong" Marcos Jr., as well as for the political future of Vice President Sara Duterte. It also highlights the ongoing debate about the role and power of the Philippines' constitutional bodies.
Bridge Questions: What is the actual evidence against Vice President Sara Duterte? How does this impeachment proceeding fit into the broader political landscape in the Philippines? What would change your mind about the legitimacy of these impeachment complaints?
